Introduction and context
NQF snapshot
The planned national qualifications framework (NQF) has not yet been adopted by law. So far, Lebanon has only defined levels, 8, and descriptors. In practice, work on the NQF is in abeyance because of the country’s continuing political deadlock and the priority given to handling the presence in the country of many Syrian refugees.
Although the Ministry of Education and Higher Education led an earlier NQF project, the governance structure and the body that would manage the QF has not yet been officially decided.
Educational, social, economic and political context
Lebanon has a unique socio-political setting, due to the fragile institutional situation, the growing pressure of the Syrian crisis and the absence of a government following the elections in May 2018. The country´s unique features of a confessionally -based political system and challenging geopolitical environment have made it difficult for governments to implement reforms, which are often blocked or slowed down due to changing priorities and problems in reaching consensus. The spill-over effects of the Syrian conflict represent an increasing threat to Lebanese internal security and impact on all aspects of socio-political and economic life.
Lebanon’s total population has increased by more than 25% in 6 years, from 4.30 million in 2010 to just over 6 million in 2016. [1] The influx of an estimated 1.5 million Syrian refugees since 2011, in addition to the presence of Palestinian refugees caught in a protracted refugee situation (estimates vary between 174.422 [2] and 469.331 [3]), has strained public finances, infrastructure and service delivery. The Syrian refugees in Lebanon are generally young; approximately 65% of all registered Syrians are under the age of 25.
Lebanon is a middle-income country with an open and largely service-oriented economy that has a strong commercial tradition of domestic free trade and investment policies. The service sector constitutes more than 70 % of the country´s GDP and employs around 70% of the work force. Industry amounts to one quarter of GDP and agriculture 6% (World Bank, world development indicators). SMEs remain the main form of business organisation, particularly micro and small enterprises and there is a large informal sector in the country. Economic growth was high in recent years (up to 8-9% although mostly jobless) but significantly dropped since 2011 and the forecast for the near future is not promising.
An average of 44.2 per cent of the working-age population was estimated to be economically active in 2017 (ILO KILM), with female labour force participation rates just over 21 per cent compared with 66.9 per cent among males aged over 15. The low employment and low activity rates of females can be attributed to social, cultural and economic factors. The unemployment rate was estimated at 6.3 per cent in 2017, with youth (aged 15–24) unemployment estimated at 16.5 per cent. In addition, the country is affected by huge migration flows in terms of a high influx of foreign workers and a large number of skilled Lebanese people seeking employment abroad.
Although Lebanon’s economy is characterised by a proportionately bigger private sector compared to most countries in the region, and a population known for its entrepreneurial spirit (incidence of self-employment [4] amounts to 30% of the total employment), it remains extremely vulnerable to domestic and regional politics and civil unrest.
Lebanon has a relatively low-skilled [5] labour force, though still amongst the most highly-skilled in the region[6]. Almost 20% of adults have attained higher education, the third highest percentage country of the region after Israel and Palestine, while 12% of adults have not followed any education, which is also much lower than the average percentage in the region. Males are slightly more highly skilled than females, although the difference is not as sharp as it is for participation in the labour market.
The education and training system in Lebanon is among the best-performing in the Middle East and North Africa region. Education is traditionally highly valued. In recent years, there has been an increasing socio-political awareness of the importance of education and training for sustainable and cohesive socioeconomic growth. In this context, the Lebanese government - with the support of UNICEF and the ILO - has recently launched the National Strategic Framework for TVET 2018-2022. This proposed strategy is a key outcome of the Government’s TVET initiative and seeks to widen access and improve the quality of TVET provision.
As stated in the National Strategic Framework for TVET, instead of TVET being perceived as an alternative pathway to productive and decent work, young Lebanese generally associate TVET with academic failure and poor-quality provision. The association of TVET-level jobs with low wages, poor working conditions and lack of career prospects has discouraged youth from enrolling in TVET courses at secondary and post-secondary levels. As a result, just over 26 per cent of students enrolled in secondary education opted for a vocational track in 2015.
The low attractiveness of the VET system could be due to the weak links to the labour market, which exacerbates the difficult transition young people experience from education to the labour market. One in four youth aged 15 to 24 (almost one in three young women) are not in employment, education or training (ILOSTAT, 2007), which, while lower than the average in the region, still represents an important concern.
[1] UNDP, World population prospects, 2016
[2] According to the government’s Lebanese-Palestinian Dialogue Committee census figure covering 12 refugee camps and about 150 informal Palestinian communities released in December 2017
[3] UNRWA figures
[4] This indicator measures the share of self-employers as a proportion of total employment. Self-employers includes employers, own-account workers, members of producers’ cooperatives and contributing family workers.
[5] Educational attainment is frequently used as a proxy measure of the skills associated with a given level of education and available in the population, and to the labour force. Higher levels of educational attainment are associated with several positive individual and social outcomes (see also OECD Education at a Glance, 2015).
[6] Traditionally Lebanon retains high education standards with a large proportion of private education at all levels.
Policy objectives
Education and training reforms
The Lebanese national qualifications framework (LQF) should be able to classify all qualifications and certificates issued by the different sectors of the education and training system. In particular, the LQF should ensure:
- (a) transparency and readability of qualifications delivered in Lebanon and their relevance for the labour market;
- (b) recognition of qualifications based on well- defined competences whether acquired via formal, non-formal or informal education;
- (c) mobility between different sectors of the education system;
- (d) coherence with qualifications frameworks of other countries.
The NQF is one of the building blocks of the National Strategic Framework for action, TVET 2018-2022 (NSF). In 2012, the NQF was piloted in selected sectors, including education, agro-food, health, electrical works, and hospitality. Within the National Strategic Framework for TVET 2018-2022 (NSF), the development of a National Qualification System (NQS), centred on a competency-based approach to training and testing allows for better signalling of graduate skills to employers, is foreseen. The intention is to adopt the NQF with eight levels of qualifications in order to classify the various certificates and diplomas and establish pathways between them.
International cooperation
The NQF is one of the components of the World Bank Education reform programme, which had planned to take the work of a project supported by the European Training Foundation (ETF) project forward. However, due to difficulties in the legislation approval process, the change at high policy decision-making level and the increased influx of the Syrian refugees, this project component was not implemented. The NQF is currently being addressed for the construction sector by the EU-funded project, which is being implemented by GIZ ‘Improving Quality of Vocational Training and Education for Lebanese Youth’.
The need to bring coherence to the many and diverse qualifications offered in Lebanon remains a priority, although international cooperation is now focused on issues linked to access and education for all as a result of the need to give education to the Syrian refugees currently living in the country.
Levels and use of learning outcomes
NQF levels and level descriptors
An eight-level structure is planned.
The descriptors have been under the descriptors knowledge, skills and competences.
Qualifications
No legal definition yet as the NQF itself has not been adopted in law. Qualifications have been developed on a learning outcomes basis in the construction sector.
Access, progression and credit
No further development in this area.
Use of learning outcomes
The NQF’s descriptors are outcomes-based.
NQF scope and structure
The Lebanese NQF is intended to be lifelong learning in scope, covering general, VET and higher education qualifications.
Stakeholder involvement and institutional arrangements
Legal basis of NQF
There is no NQF adopted by law.
Governance and institutional arrangements for the NQF
At the time of the ETF-led project on the NQF, the Ministry of Education and Higher Education coordinated the project and hosted the NQF working group. However, the institutional arrangements proposed by the NQF working group were never officially approved. Therefore, no institution is currently leading the NQF.
Roles and functions of actors and stakeholders
The NQF working group brought together representatives from the different sectors of the education sector but no other stakeholders such as employers, although officially invited, participated.
Resources and funding
Except for the earlier ETF-led project funded by the Italian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, there has been no other donor support for the development of the NQF.
Quality assurance of qualifications
There is a traditional approach to quality assurance related to the qualifications cycle with a quality control emphasis. In VET, QA systems operate but need to be modernised. Currently, they include internal and external evaluation of providers, addressing curricula etc. There is formal teacher training and an education inspectorate. These of course bear on systems relevant to qualifications such as standards and assessment, but there are no existing mechanisms to validate quality of qualifications.
Since the NQF has not yet been adopted by law and therefore has not been implemented, the NQF has not introduced new QA tools.
The Ministry of Education and Higher Education, through the Directorate for Higher Education has been working for more than 10 years on creating a quality assurance agency for higher education. However, the law to create the agency has not been approved and is currently blocked.
There is a traditional QA approach with regulatory mechanisms such as accreditation, inspection, examinations etc. but no distinct legal framework per se. Ministries licence provider institutions, set standards for programmes, set exam standards, and run an inspectorate. There is no independent QA agency yet. However, there have been discussions about establishing a QA Agency for Higher Education.
Lebanon participates in the ETF Forum for Quality Assurance in VET.
Recognising and validating non-formal and informal learning and learning pathways
There is no mechanism in place for validation of non-formal and informal learning.
NQF implementation
Inclusion of qualifications in a register
No register has been formally adopted. The ETF-led project had developed methods and procedures.
Monitoring, evaluation and review of the NQF
None has taken place yet, given the very early stage of development of the qualifications framework.
Impact for end-users
The NQF is not functional yet.
Referencing to regional frameworks
No referencing to regional frameworks has been considered yet. The Arab Standard Classification of Occupations (ASCO) has been a reference instrument to inform development of the LQF.
Important lessons and future plans
Progress on the NQF would be achievable via the framework of the NSF, but other conditions currently inhibit progress, in particular political stasis and the national priority accorded to responding to the Syrian refugee crisis.
Abbreviations
ASCO Arab standard classification of occupations
ETF European Training Foundation
MEHE Ministry of Education and Higher Education
NSF national Strategic Framework for action, TVET 2018-2022
NQF national qualifications framework
SEMED Southern and Eastern Mediterranean region
UNDP United Nations Development Programme
UNWRA United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East
VET vocational education and training
VTE vocational and technical education
Please log in or sign up to comment.